Author Thread
Post actions
Oh so this was yours, I gave you an 8, so I liked it.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
clarity pushed a little too much for me, tree in the back looks like it's beginning to halo, sky is a little grainy and I wish that rock in the foreground was sharp... Those are the faults in my opinion, but still I do like this image a lot and with the above said, 7.
Post actions
I would be curious to see this in color. I think it was a bold choice though to go with black and white.
Post actions
Beautifully done in b & w - I find this quite a moving image, but peaceful.
Post actions
The composition works well although the brightness of the water seems a little out of balance with the relative brightness of the sky.
Post actions
Nice exposure and scene, not so sure I like the halo around the tree.
Post actions
The downside of these kind of pictures is that it's hard to make them stick out among the rest and it also makes it hard to vote on.
Post actions
Post actions
I really like how the tree in this image is out in the water, while the rock is close. Seems backwards to me.
Post actions
Very beautiful scene. Amazing that tree is growing out in the water... nice!
Post actions
Nice leading line with the water. Good contrast.
Post actions
Post actions
halos around the tree give away overprocessing.
Post actions
I like the balance between the rock and the tree - as though they're distant cousins who still keep in touch.
Post actions
Big halos around the tree makes this look weird
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
