Author Thread
Comments Made During the Challenge
08/29/2004 08:06:57 AMPost actions
Cute. I like your use of balck and white.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/27/2004 10:17:40 PMPost actions
A wonderful picture, I'm not sure about the white edge. It helps draw you to the 'meat' of the picture, but I'm not sure it was needed. Still I give it a 9.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/27/2004 03:49:02 PMPost actions
Nice idea, but wher's the cutie's face.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/26/2004 04:06:10 PMPost actions
overprocessed. don't like how the child is surrounded by a dark area and then completely white.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/26/2004 01:11:04 PMPost actions
Setzler Comment:
Some general ratings (1-10): These are some elements that I look for in great photographs, in no specific order…
Visual Appeal: 4
Subject Appeal: 4
Compositional Appeal: 5
Effective use of color/bw: 5
Creativity: 3
Theme/Storytelling qualities: 7
Title: 6
Additional Comments:
This is one of those photos that most people outside your friends/family will find difficult to embrace.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/26/2004 01:07:35 PMPost actions
cute but background doesnt work for me
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/25/2004 10:12:20 PMPost actions
really don't like the whitening around the image. It justdoesn't work for this photo. cut the tag too :)
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/25/2004 11:51:03 AMPost actions
She does love that cow! Might have burned out a little more around her. The amount of shadow is a little distracting
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/24/2004 09:17:57 PMPost actions
very cute. Should be a postcard.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/24/2004 08:26:55 AMPost actions
This is a cute baby pic, but doesn't really fit the idea of a nude photo to me. A nice memory for you though.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/24/2004 07:26:46 AMPost actions
Now as far as sweetness goes, this is a ten. For photographic qualities is isn't so high I am afraid. The white fade is very cheap looking and ruins this shot.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/23/2004 02:35:24 PMPost actions
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/23/2004 01:53:26 PMPost actions
This is a very sweet image that will be treasued forever. I'm not particularly fond of the "fading border" presentation, but it is well done.
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/23/2004 10:17:53 AMPost actions
too cute; more a family album shot
Photographer found comment helpful.
08/23/2004 01:24:31 AMPost actions
cute! i feel rather than whitening out the parts you did you should have instead applied a slight guassian blur to them and a unsharpmask to the baby and his toy.
Photographer found comment helpful.