A very nice image that meets the challenge well. I'm sure many will comment about too much grain, but I personally feel it works well and compliments the gritty subway surroundings.
Meets the challenge. I guess you were going for a grainy look here. The motion you got with the blurred logo didn't extend to the passenger on the train. I gave this a 3.
Quite a grainy photo but I think it adds to the effect which is what I hope you were going for! A little blurred from movement which I personally don't like - could have been either more or less - but still a nice photo.
This shot almost looks like a lithograph... I'm glad you didn't get sucked into the 'neat image' pit of dispair and clean this up. The noise makes a fairly mundane image interesting IMHO.
and immediately after taking this shot you were wrestled to the ground by an MTA cop... nice gritty feel, i like the lines and the tone. and, thank you for not being too chicken (i am) to take pics in the subway.