rotate
crop
adjusted saturation and temp
adjusted exposure and contrast
sharpened
smoothed the neck
applied eye bright x 3
cloned a spot on the eye
smoothed face, chest and arm
cloned spots off background
Statistics
Place: 59 out of 95 Avg (all users): 5.3571 Avg (commenters): 5.3333 Avg (participants): 5.0741 Avg (non-participants): 5.4402 Views since voting: 1031 Views during voting: 441 Votes: 238 Comments: 11 Favorites: 0
LOL! I am not sure how to get past those two issues though as they are the biggest. I would be interested in seeing the original on this one to understand better where you started from. But let's see what else I can add. I think you are a bit too heavy on bus. Cropping a bit off the right side - maybe just past the vertical line, would give you a better balance in the image. The other things that stand out are the over saturation and smoothness. Sorry - keeps dragging me back. Your model has a good gaze. I would be interested in seeing her maybe looking at me from the same head position. I know Manny has his models looking away often, but the gaze through the camera connecting with the viewer is a strong thing. But really, the issues you brought up are the biggest reason for your score. A different crop and a more relaxed editing hand (and a tweak on her skin tones to mellow them out even if those colors are the natural ones) would get you a different score. You have a very pretty model there and would be good to use her more often if for nothing else than portrait experimentation.
sorry, i should be more constructive. not knowing your skill level, i would suggest in the future to mask out only the skin on your model and do your smoothing on that. i personally use Digital Gem Airbrush filter at about a 60% application to smooth the skin nicely w/out looking artificial.