I like this one a lot... they look like stones, and the ligthing is fabulous... you've pulled of a terrific texture shot here. One of my favs for this challenge.
Great photo! It looks like a cliff of chocolate. I like how you took chocolate and used an original idea to make it more interesting. Also, the focus is great & the background is absolutely perfect. 9!
I believe you that it's chocolate, but it sure doesn't look enticing. I would not want a photo of this on my wall, no offense. I would prefer to see this chocolate a little more smooth or gooey. Though it may taste good, I can't imagine it. The photo does not draw me in. I like the crop, composition and color, but the lighting could be brighter I think, more contrast too...
I love the way this chocolate looks rocky. It looks as though it will last a very long time, as it is a 'rugged chocolate'. I like the nice plain background and the subtle shadows as well.