I'm guessing from the quality that this is a pretty radical crop of a larger image. In a way, it makes it more interesting - gritty - than a perfectly smooth image might be.
looks out of focus and the and the subject is in the center but it dosen't exaclty run parralel to a vertical line, I'm not sure how you did this so I don't really know what else to say
It is not imediately apparent what it is I am looking at, therefore what action is stopped. I have a feeling something has happened but I don't know what.
Ok.. I have spent a lot of time looking at this... It's an excellent shot. The top part of the image is a little out of focus. I'm bothered by the vertical lines in the image... I don't know why they are there. If they are there because of a scanner, then shame. If they were put there intentionally, then why? I thought for a moment that they may be part of a background but I can see them in the top part of the water as well and through the water.... I'll wait to see what happens on this one. If it stays, it's getting a decent score. Improvements would have been tighter focus on the top and removal of those verticals....