Great lighting and contrast in tone to really suit this in B/W and it certainly shows balance, the horizon is on an acute angle but i don't think that detracts from it so iam guessing this must have been on a bit of an angle. excellent work (9)
Really cool. I am not sure if you really need the bottom part of the image (is it a beach?)
This is well thought out and nicely done. I will score this really. If it was my own image, I would increase the contrast a bit - just a personal choice that is)