Author Thread
Post actions
Top 5 finish, nicely done I really like this one!
Post actions
Though the color is lovely, the B&W most certainly doesn't suck. :-)
Post actions
This shot has a certain smoothness to it. One of my favourites in the challenge. Congrats on the great finish.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Yep knew it was a good one, well done on this gorgeous shot!@
Post actions
Wonderful lighting, all in all an exquisite image. Congrats on 6th place, Trevor.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Very nice image; not so centered would make it even better.
Post actions
Nicely put together... and I'm a sucker for anything that has to do with music.
Post actions
Very well composed and nice lighting.
Post actions
Setup and composition is excellent, as is lighting. Where's the candle in the holder?
Post actions
Wonderful lighting, composition and softness. I feel this shot will do very well in the challenge. 10
Post actions
soft lighting and soft focus is nice. the vignette works well
Post actions
Probably the best set up I've seen so far.. 9
Post actions
I like the concept and the dramatic lighting. A little cluttered though, i think it would look better with fewer roses. 7
Post actions
I wish I had your patience and intimate knowledge of lighting!
Post actions
This is a nice composition, but I think there is a tad too much processing going on - a simpler processed image would have looked more appealing.
Post actions
how routine. 6 ETA that sounded incredibly cold and cruel i'm sorry i should be more specific i was hoping to see some original work in this challenge i guess i'm in the camp of "tired of wine glasses and colored pencils" crew in DPC. this really was a well executed shot i thus scored it a 6 based on it's tech merits
Post actions
I really like your tones in this, but to me it is just a bit over cluttered...Personally I like simplistic still life pictures...mind you I'm not saying this is bad...in comparison to the other...you at least got the general idea
Post actions
Now this is a true still life photo, very nice composition, should rate well. 9
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
