I'm not sure I understand the title. Is this a remake of a real stock image? To me this appears to be a great artistic shot, but not something I would sell as a stock image.
I like this image, you have been creative and the colouring makes it look old and antique like.
I'm not sure however if a company would want to use it as a stock image so I took one point off. 8
I think that is not right for this challenge, i see a phone, an old photo but not the operator... maybe if I had seen also a desk (old) would be better... but is a good shot so i gave you a 6.
Love the vintage quality of this image, and the desat. I'm not crazy about the composition though - the phone seems cramped out of the image and hanging at an odd angle.
Interesting idea. I like the coloring and vignetting for this time period. I could probably see this being accepted to a stock site, but probably not as the operator theme.