Author Thread
Post actions
Congratulations on your ribbon! I love the whole idea and the execution was beautifully done. Gorgeous lighting!
Post actions
Post actions
Clever idea, congrats on the ribbon!
Post actions
I like this very much I like the simplicity of it
Post actions
congrats on the ribbon. I actually proposed to my wife using this very method!
Post actions
V.good idea, lighting is well done. u used external flash ?
Post actions
Excellent pic Thamer! Superb lighting...
Post actions
Congratulations. Very nice shot. Simple but effective.
Post actions
Another shot with excellent lighting.
Post actions
wonderful! fantastically done, and a terrific idea! :)
Post actions
Good job! Congratulations on Third place.
Post actions
Great job! You're on a roll lately. Might as well add you to my favorites now- you're defintiely a dangerous competitor. ;-)
Post actions
Congratulations!! Fantastic job :) I feel honored to be in the top 3 with you!!
Post actions
Post actions
Congrats Thamer!
Post actions
Post actions
WOW, I wasn't expecting a ribbon with a 6.4, i'm totally shocked!
Post actions
My warm congratulations. Enjoy, enjoy.
Post actions
Congratulations...beautiful shot! :o)
Post actions
WoooW Congrats on your ribbon man ;) Very well deserved :D
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Great idea. Nice composition and the good colors.
Post actions
this one is just too cute :)
Post actions
Well lit with good composition and sharpness.
Post actions
This one gets my "how sweet" vote :)
Post actions
Post actions
the best fortune cookie in the challenge. good lighting, clear text, focus where it should be... oh, and nice color and composition. crumbs but not too many. good stuff.
Post actions
This photograph is so cute! It provokes emotion, and I love a photo that makes me emotional! 9 :)
Post actions
Post actions
Good detail, DOF and lighting - crumbs are a bit distracting. Nice effort.
Post actions
My voting guidelines for this competiton: Does the photo meet the challenge (does the photo contain words): 1-NO, 2-YES
If you were to remove the words from the photo, is the photo itself interesting: 0-NO, 1-SOMEWHAT, 2-YES, 3-DEFINITELY
The quality of the actual photograph: 0-NEEDS WORK, 1-GOOD, 2-GREAT, 3-SUPERB
Does this picture WOW me: 0-NO, 1-YES, 2-DEFINITELY
Total Score: 8
Post actions
love the lighting and the idea, great.
Post actions
Simple yet elegant. There was another fortune cookie - but yours leaves it in the dust. Things that are perfect: lighting, lighting, choice of colors, composition, lighting, dark background, and of course, lighting. Not quite perfect, but close: The top edge of the back part of the cookie is a tad soft - another f-stop or two would have been better. You should finish way up there.
Post actions
I hope that turns out to be a good fortune! Very nice lighting.
Post actions
Nice idea and very nice lighting. The cookie is not very clear unfortunately. Maybe a ring would have made more impact.
Post actions
Nice surprise. Did she/he say yes? Nice photo. The crumbs make it look real. I like the lighting.
Post actions
Lovely idea. I hope it's real and that somebody is very happy right now. Good job.
Post actions
Sorry but I'm already married.LOL Great photo with good lighting.
Post actions
Nice idea... I always love the fortune cookie entries. Wish the colors had been a bit brighter and happier to fit the theme, but still, nice job!
Post actions
Good ompact. Right to the point.
Post actions
Post actions
Cute idea, nicely done pic, too bad so many people did the fortune cookie. I think the proposal sets you apart (and it made a great hint for my boyfriend for romantic ideas in the future!). A little blur along the top right edge of the cookie, maybe a DOF issue.
Post actions
It's a surprising idea, well executed but I think more light would have suited the message better. There's so much drama in it now, whereas is should be light and happy. still a 7
Post actions
Wonderful, wonderful composition? Lighting is good as well. I somehow like the fact that photo is off-centered.
Surprise Proposal
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
