A very nice shot. I would have cropped a little more off the bottom since that portion showing on the bottom is a little distracting. What is that a reflection of?
I never drink milk out of a wine glass even though I have the very best milk in the world available to me.. 'Clover'. it's my favorite drink.... good idea made better without a wine glass!
I like the composition of the photo, the white milk with chocolate cookies is a striking contrast, but the photos isn't sharp enough (at least on my monitor).
This is a really great photo and advertisement. Cookies are in great focus, but focus seems a little lost on the glass of milk. Also, I'm not sure whether you need the reflections in the bottom of thte picture, but doesn't necessarily take away from the photo. Definitely a 9!
Great image in many ways. And a great tie in to the theme. Following the rule of thirds would help here I think. If you could move the image down in the frame so the milk and the cookies hit the top and bottom third gridlines, the composition would have been stronger. I think a slightly shorter crop would also help, too.
Just a little glare on the table near the base of the glass and I would think some of the bottom could have been croped. I like the shot though.. BTW I dip mine lol.