Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Not enough contrast. If left 25% were cropped out it would have more focus
Post actions
Great duotone. Caption makes it.
Post actions
Post actions
I don't know if the sepia tone works very well for this picture. It's pretty in-your-face and almost detracts from the picture. Very clear and sharp, though. muckpond.
Post actions
Like it! Can imagine immediately the whole story behind it and how it moves a whole city!
Post actions
this is so flat and I can't even tell what mess you are speaking of.
Post actions
I think BW is appropriate here, but I don't understand what the mess is about. I suspect a strip mine or something, but I could be wrong. 6 nards656
Post actions
Ok you managed to loose me on this one.
Post actions
I can't tell exactly what "this Place" is.
Post actions
looks like a screen of somekind...i can see excavator teeth marks on the bank
Post actions
I like the sepia toning here, but the colours look a little washed out. Also I think that a couple of inches cropped off the top would help.
Post actions
There, no doubt is a story here. The sepia tone, however, to me, evokes a more nostalgic feeling. It's possible b & w or color would give the image more impact to illustrate the story the title suggests.
Post actions
I think maybe this would work better in color. Every thing is just too much the same shade with the sepia tone.
Post actions
Like the tone, but what am I looking at? Is this a mine shaft?
Post actions
Very good image and to the point--andrewm
Post actions
Good approach to show the enormity of the problem. Can decide if I like the lack of color, but will yield to your judgement.
Post actions
The color doesn't work for me here. Would have been better in color. Nice focus and good crop. Decent execution. PTL8
Post actions
Good clearity and DOF. Slight smudge on the right in the sky, but a good shot overall.
Post actions
Compostions seems to be a little average. Perhaps more lighting adjustments or more shadowing.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
