Author Thread
Post actions
Congratulations on a still pretty good 30th place. Imo it should have finished much higher up. I gave it a 8. But of course I am no expert when it comes to judging catalog shots and reading through the comments this image received I am learning a lot about what can make or break a really excellent catalog shot. That's why this site and these challenges are so good for improving one's photographic skills and eye.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The composition works and the colors work well together. Nice.
Post actions
Excelent shot well set up , like the reflection
Post actions
I think it's weird to see the stem inside one bottle, but not both. Personally, I prefer without the stem because it looks cleaner.
Post actions
Really like the way you set this up and the reflective surface really adds to the photograph
Post actions
Post actions
Good geometrics in this, though it may imply one is better than the other in some strange way. (Commenting only.)
Post actions
A classic. You have done it justice. Humorous titles don't hurt, either.
Post actions
great. soft focus is working great on this. very well done.
Post actions
nice use of angles - i am just not sold on the lighting here - the aramis on the left should be better illuminated
Post actions
is it really that colour? urgh I wouldn't buy it lol. well executed shot
Post actions
Very accomplished execution. Would have liked a bit more at the top. Amongst best in challenge. 8
Post actions
Good lighting and nice use of reflections. Clean image.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
