Author Thread
Post actions
Originally posted by h2:
Still not keen on the noise :) but otherwise well done, especially for an outdoor shot. Congrats on top 10!
Post actions
Still not keen on the noise :) but otherwise well done, especially for an outdoor shot. Congrats on top 10!
Post actions
Congrats on the top 10!! whoot!
Post actions
Congratulations on your final top 10 place. Very well done!
Post actions
Congratulations with an excellent top 10 finish.
Post actions
great! looks like a magazine ad from the eighties, has the film look.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
This is real classy, I'd buy it, great work!
Post actions
Very good. Love the way the color brings your eye to the product name immediately.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Not a fan of the selective color with B/W but in this particular shot looks awesome. I like the combination with the color of the cologne. composition also works for me.
Post actions
Excellent layout and very good use of shallow DOF. I like the grain. Very realistic as a magazine ad. Should do very well in voting. (Commenting only.)
Post actions
Post actions
Nice job. If this was a selective desaturation, the effect worked for you nicely. Good color scheme.
Post actions
i like the choice of crop and composition - i would suggest this looks more ad like rather than product like - but no points off for that...
Post actions
Selective desat put to good use.
Post actions
Stylish execution. Nice desat. 8
Post actions
Overall it's a splendid photo. Couple of items taking away from it for me are 1) noise - don't really expect it in a product shot IMO, and 2) I think the comp would be better served with about 30 pixels taken off the bottom. All JMO of course. Good luck in the challenge.
Post actions
Very pretty. I think the unusual crop is pleasing to the eye, but not particularly appropriate for a catalog or advertisement. Same with the image grain, which I personally love, but not for that application.
Post actions
good crop and lighting. a bit much noise. placement and spreading of droplets could be enhanced
Post actions
THis makes me think about an advert. It's got a bit of a murder scene vibe to it. A bit chilling and cold. Cool though
Post actions
Nice shot. The grains in the background bothers a bit. You could have cleaned it, I think.
Post actions
Nice shot, but it needed some noise reduction to eliminate that grain some.
Post actions
Post actions
Selective desaturation works very well here.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
