Hi, Critique Club here...
I think this did pretty well for a free study. I like the composition and the colors (colours ;) ) of it. The technicals are right on the money.
I think what would have elevated this into the 6+ range would have been some action, like the wheel spinning. Otherwise, while pretty in its own right, it's a bit static.
I definately don't think it deserved the scores lower than 4. I don't get the voters around here.
If I voted in this challenge, I would have given this a 6. |