Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I really like this photograph, and your subject is perfect for black and white. I like the composition and the sense of repeated forms and angles. I especially like the way it fades to black in the upper right hand corner. lhall
Post actions
nice set of wheels and composition...works well in greyscale
Post actions
Great shot. You can see how the wheel work to move the train. B & W works well here. I like it. Nice one. PTL
Post actions
Good detail and fine composition--the strength of the construction and the mechanical details are shown in a powerful photo andrewm
Post actions
John, I feel I should complain about something. The rocks at lower right are blown out. And it is so bad of you to have great DOF. 7 JEM
Post actions
The contrast and composition gives this photo real strength. Great image.
Post actions
Superb BW. I can even see the thread on the bolts! Well done!
Post actions
Post actions
Great shot! You got a really clear close-up. This is the first time I have ever noticed the braking mechanism on the trains wheels!
Post actions
I wish the bottom right was a little less burnt out otherwise great shot. 7. byetko.
Post actions
This is one of my favourites this week. The low contrast gives it a gentle feel for such a heavy subject, perhaps a touch of nostalgia there. In contrast, so to speak, the bottom right seems too contrasty. It could probably do without the small area of light, top left, but I'm nitpicking now. Very good.
Post actions
Post actions
This is a super b&w...wow. Maybe the ground on the right is a bit blown out but could easily be fixed. Just a good photo. Job well done. Justine.
Post actions
I think the black and white works well with this photo... I wonder if sepia would look even better?
Post actions
nice black and white with good tones.
Post actions
Very nice. Black and white works well for this one. 9/10! erin_m02
Post actions
Great shot! Love the composition and tones...9 Lisa
Post actions
Nice clean shot. The dirt almost gives this shot a film grain look. (8)
Post actions
Nice picture. I found the framing a bit harsh on the near wheel.
Post actions
Lovely definition and clarity. Could have been sepia toned??
Post actions
Meets the challenge 10
Post actions
decent shot. Nice lead in with depth.
Post actions
Greetings... I particularly like your photo this week... I'm definitely inspired by trains... I like your composition here and I love the black and white as well... great shot :) - setzler
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
