You fell prey to the "voters hate guns, and voters particularly hate kids with guns" phenomenon. Been there a couple times myself. I guess some subjects are too sensitive to see any humor in. Eh, whatcanyado. :-)
Not much feeling of perspective as there is a lack of depth. The barrels should have been right up in your face and not so close to the bottom of the frame. Also the focus should be on the barrels with the girl subjected to a greater depth of field. 5
WTH..the age of the model and the subject of the photo don't work together for me. It does elicit an emotion, but one of being disturbed, so the photo succeeded in that area. Regarding the technicals, the eyes and the brim are nice and sharp. The photo grain gives this almost a film noir feel. Sorry this isn't what you wanted, lol.
The perspective is all wrong. If you are looking for ways to increase the feeling of perspective, there are a few tricks that you can use, namely:
* Place directly lit subjects close to the camera and dark ones further away.
* Same as above but with contrasty subjects on the front
* Same as above with focus on the front
You went against all of these so it's easy to understand where the eye of the viewer is going to rest. IMHO this is a fortunate side effect as the viewer's eye will rest on the background because sincerely I can't understand all these mixings of kids and guns, but it must be me.
Good exposure, good use of B&W, excellent composition and fantastic model.
4* for those.