Greetings from the Critique Club
Congratulations on the top 20 result.
How to critique this image and add any value? Well, a little challenging from my side as I think it is rathe a well done image.
You got just the right amount of blur in the water which is good. The detail in the ice is excellent. There are no blown out highlights at all. The color treatment in post processing enhances the cold feeling.
Perhaps the only thing that may have persuaded me to score it higher than I did (I gave you a 7 by the way), would have been a slight change in composition. I perhaps would have liked it to be a wider angle with a little bit more context. However, that is only a small personal taste thing.
Again, well done on a good score and placement in this challenge.
Sarah |