Greetings from the Critique Club
First of all, let me welcome you to DPC. I know that you registered a while ago, but it seems you have only just started submitting to the challenges.
I am sorry that this did not score higher for you as I believe it is a decent shot. Even though for me it does meet the challenge, I am thinking the only reason it could have scored below 5 is because the majority of voters did not feel it fully met the challenge topic.
I wonder if you had focused more on the fingers and the ice cube itself if you may have scored a bit higher? To my mind it is a decent shot and definitely did not deserve a 4.8. I gave it a 6.
Sarah |