I'm probably not the best to critique this shot as I am not a "foodie", but based on your comments received during the challenge, you've pleased many of those folks who do like food shots, so that's good! To me, this looks pretty well lit although there are a few reflections that a softer light might have prevented. Colors are good and seem very natural. The only suggestion I'd make, and not sure how you do it, is to ensure the spoon is clean above the gravy line, if that makes sense. And good job catching the gravy as it drips!
I love shallow dof food shots but I think you could have opened up the aperture a little wider or focused more squarely on the sauce. It's a nice shot but I think you're a little off to the right...
Very good food shot and nice drip. I would have given it a different title, "suckling pig" doesn't really sound appetizing! But I am voting on the photo, not the title.