Author Thread
Post actions
Very evocative. I can't help thinking of Dylan Dog, but that's probably my very personal cultural filter.
Post actions
Very nice! Congrats on the blue.
Post actions
Molto bello. Felicitazioni. :)
Post actions
Instant fav!! Congratulations.
Post actions
wow this is so good.
Post actions
[quote=KarenNfld] I'm guessing that this is by tate . [/quote.]
Post actions
Wonderful image! Will you be making this available as a print?
Post actions
Thanks Coley, it's a proud to be confused with you :) Paolo
Originally posted by Coley:
I would like to thank everyone for voting for me on this shot ... wait a minute this is not my shot :D
had taken it .
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful. Great use of high contrast and centered composition.
Post actions
I would like to thank everyone for voting for me on this shot ... wait a minute this is not my shot :D
had taken it .
Post actions
Excellent work - and a well deserved ribbon.
Post actions
I don't usually give bluebirds to top 10s, but this was just too wonderful to pass up. It feels kind of silly to give my award to someone whose profile is as incredible as yours -- but what the heck!
link to the posthumous thread
Post actions
Oh, I should of thought of that. My first thought was Coley as well, but it just didn't seem his style at all.
Post actions
wonderful, well deserved!
Post actions
Right Hopper :)
Originally posted by hopper:
well done, you stole my idea :)
Originally posted by hopper:
copy someone who is popular ... no one will know till after the challenge is over
Post actions
Wow, amazing shot,congrats on the well deserved Blue!
Post actions
well done, you stole my idea :)
Originally posted by hopper:
copy someone who is popular ... no one will know till after the challenge is over
Post actions
Congrats on the Blue! I like everything about this image! Superb!
Post actions
Post actions
during the votes, i have predicted this as a Blu Ribbon, I'm very happy to have guessed!!
Post actions
Congrats! Quite a feat ribboning in such incredible competition!
Post actions
Big congratulations! Me too confused with Coley. I really like the way you have made it interesting by breaking the rules of composition!
Post actions
Stunning, fascinating. Love it! Many congrats on the blue.
Post actions
Very creative and intriguing... and well deserved blue! Congratulations!!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
ok my first guess (Coley ) was wrong (I should spend more time at DPC), but now thanks to 1x I know EXACTLY who you are, Mr. Windtale :)
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Wonderful "story telling" capture....The rest of the story...??
Post actions
That bag is too big for carry on, sir. :P
Post actions
I would even eat my hat - or yours - if this is not you, Windtale . Wonderful image. 10.
Post actions
Could this be the last we see of the Umbrella Man??...this is Coley
Post actions
Post actions
Hum, all the makings of a Coley shot, even the U-man is in the photo...
Post actions
Great image. Composition and contrast excellent... and the subject is intriguing. Another example of the wonderful quality of images in this challenge. Well done.
Coley
Post actions
ok now I know you're not Coley...still a great shot
Post actions
I love this photo, particularly the symmetry. b/w is excellent.
Post actions
Must be Coley! Truly wonderful!
Post actions
ok, this is the one that I think is Coley but I think this could also be Windtale ....hmmmm I'm going to go with Windtale
Post actions
Umbrella man ribbons again?!?!? Great shot.
Post actions
I'm attracted to men with bowlers and umbrellas. The suitcase is a bonus. :)
Post actions
Intensely creative. Love it.
Post actions
style or motif? both, I guess. metatate
Post actions
Ah, the Umbrella Man is back - although that appendage probably won't do him much good if he continues forward and steps into the sea. I like this as it is completely surreal ala the style of Magritte. The soft textures of the waves belie the wide expanse of lonely ocean. He gives pause to consider his Journey - and ours. Outstanding!
Post actions
If this is not Coley, someone has done a great job of representing him! Its a beauty!
Post actions
Don't take offense, this is so Coley, but alas it can't be because I spoted him. I'm curious.
Post actions
well, it has a story! my fav.
Post actions
I did see this on 1X so perhaps so I know this is yours windtale . It is an incredibly beautiful image, I like it a lot. I would certainly not have guessed you if I had seen it earlier.
Post actions
Now could this be Coley and his ever lasting love relationship with the black umbrella. If not, great impersonation. I love the style.
Post actions
Looks like Coley. Nice capture! 7
Post actions
So surreal! Awesome shot and perfect choice of B&W. Creativity at it's finest.
Post actions
Post actions
I'll go out on a limb and say this is Coley, purely from the subject matter. I like. Good silhouette, nice drama, good DOF, 8 from me.
Post actions
Amazing image, I really like this.
Post actions
Post actions
Oh NO, is this the last brolly man shot?? Say it ain't so!!
Post actions
Coley , I think. Just based on the umbrella and man surreal scene. Great job on this one. I like it very much!
Post actions
Hmmm...posted on 1x at the same time. So much for anonymity.
Post actions
A final escap. Love the contrast here. Maybe Coley? If, not still a grand signature here. Good Luck.
Post actions
Wow! This holds off-the-chart appeal to me! I just love every single thing about it.
Post actions
I'm guessing that this is by tate .
Post actions
FABULOUS!!!Coley? um... someone used him as a model. Whoever did it, it's excellent.
Post actions
I would guess this is Windtale !?
Post actions
I now know this to be a Windtale - this is very strong work!
Post actions
Hi Coley ! One day I will like to meet his person & take that umbrella with me :) Nice to see breaking all the rules with excellent composition!
Post actions
Oh, Mr. Coley, tell me it's not true! Can this POSSIBLY be the end of Umbrella man?
Post actions
Post actions
sophisticated image, nicely done...
Post actions
Wow, this shot just jumped out at me. I love it, here is hoping for a top 3 finish for you.
Post actions
Post actions
awesome shot! for me a Blue! i like everything here, also that we do not see but we can image seeing your photograph... beautiful!
Post actions
I'd guess Coley, but I already did. So this is someone using Coley as a model!
The end of the game
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
