challenge -- met technical -- very good lighting, i like that you have a limited range of colors but a large range of tones. very nice. composition -- love it. this tells such a nice story, there are so many things to look at, and that connect ... just perfect. the only thing that i don't like (and this is minor) is the pencil. it looks too new and the lines on it are a bit distracting. -- gr8photos.
Great composition. Would never have thought you could get so many things in without making it too busy, but you succeded. This is really neat. I'm glad you left it in color, especially since they are the color they are. Great shot. Very clear and sharp. Well cropped. Superb job. High 9. PTL
I really love this setting... this photo is quite nice :) The mood here and the soft lighting create a nice 'antique' sense... for some reason, i think the opposing diagonals created by the books and the table patterns... EXCELLENT work... = 10 - setzler
Congratulations. You have taken what could have been a boring subject matter and made it into something very appealing to the eye. I love the detail you have included. The photo is well thought out. The only detraction for me is the lighting. 8. bitz
I really love the look of this. I would like to see just a touch more light on the bottom to bring out that nice silver and glass. This is really well done and unique ! Shiiizzzam
This is a beautiful photo, but in my opinion, there are too many objects in it for it to be considered a macro. It's just not close enough on any object.