A perfect idea with just a few minor flaws. The odd lighting angle slightly washed out the bottom images in comparison to the top - the author may have intended this, but it just quite doesn't make the image more interesting. The benefit of the doubt much be part of the deliberation and in this case, the benefit goes to the author. Well done.
nicely done, i like how you arranged the pencils. i might have cropped it to the middle of the white one because i don't see the need for 2 reds to be in there, but that's just my preference.
I like this one. If I stay on a photo for more than a few seconds you've captured me and I stayed here for a bit. The white one is a little bothersome for some reason and the space between the blues on the left is distracting too. These distractions might have been overcome with just a little less crop on the two sides including about half of the end pencils. overall well done. Just a few nitpicks.Temporary rating of 5 for sorting purposes only. bump to 6.