The lighting you've chosen is interesting. And while not very interesting to me it shows that you have a good grasp of lighting control. I just wish the face had a tad bit more lighting on it.
This is fitness alright, fit the fitness the perfectly! I would liked to see better lighting though, the shadows are to dark and alot of the fitness details get lost in them and it looks like his head is split in half.
Very interesting lighting. I think high-key feels more stock-ish, but that's just me as I don't have very much experience with that sort of thing. This is a really fun photo in either case.
Excellant tone and quality slightly affected by the overly darkened subject. However it does work as demonstration of body fitness and from a technical standpoint is perfect. A little lighter subject would be a huge plus. As it stands a top fifteen image for sure - possibly a ribbon winner.