Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Nice winter scene. This is perfect for B&W.
Post actions
Beautiful shot, just a little more contrast to give it more depth is the only thing I might have done differently
Post actions
Post actions
black and white does this well
Post actions
A little oof, would pop more if it were sharper.
Post actions
Post actions
Contrast seems lacking leaving the photo somewhat flat (at least for me). Nice view.
Post actions
this is rather chaotic for me , I mean the composition there are too many 'thing' and the bw conversion is also .. well lets say it doesnt fit to my taste ;D
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Not sure if B&W was a good choice here. Also needs a little more contrast to make the scene seem a little less flat.
Post actions
A nice winter scene but it looks a bit flat.
Post actions
toning works well, some areas look over exposed?
Post actions
I like what black and white does for this. Nice shot.
Post actions
Post actions
good conversion to black and white
Post actions
Well framed. Adds to a nice shot.
Post actions
Snow is so photogenic. I like the curved trunk over the stream - I think it ties it all up very nicely.
Post actions
Interesting use of duo tone.
Post actions
love the black and white, the snow and the ice are so vivid, 8
Post actions
The image seems a little flat overall.
Post actions
this is a pleasing shot...it is a little dark is all but pleasing none the less
Post actions
This is one that I think would really benefit from larger size limits. There are so many subtle details that the size just doesn't do justice to.
Post actions
I love snow pictures. It looks cold. Hope you don't have to cross that creek.
Post actions
a little bland , maybe a just a touch more contrast would liven things up a bit
Post actions
looks pretty chilly there!
Post actions
Post actions
Nice cool tone image to show us how cold the water is.
Post actions
Wouldn't mind snowsheig past this place. Pleasant setting lovingly captured.
Post actions
I miss some details and sharpness
Post actions
I like what you were seeing here, but the lighting is flat. Perhaps some added contrast or shooting this scene at a different time of day would remedy that and substantially grow your score.
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful scene , just seems to be missing a little to give it the wow factor.
Post actions
Good pic but nothing dramatic for me. Needs a bit more pop to it.
Post actions
Post actions
contrast seems a little off.... you have very white patches of snow, mixed with gray/yellow patches, creating a very sickly effect,
Post actions
A little flat for me. Too much light in some areas. Would have looked better in b/w and more contrast I think.
Post actions
Pretty landscape and you have composed it well. The times in the image are a bit muddy though - not a full range of blacks, whites and tones in between.
Post actions
The whites aren't white enough and the blacks are black enough. But the composition works well enough. The whole image feels rather soft.
Post actions
While I like your composition, I do find the photo to be a bit busy.
Post actions
This has a nice calm feel to it, after 100+ votes it's a nice place to be..
Post actions
I can see this as a Christmas card. What a calm and beautiful snow scene. It's subtle and may not have the WOW factor of some but I really like its simplicity.
Post actions
Nice winter landscape with the river going from the right to the left.
Post actions
Captured the feel of the scene well
Post actions
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
