Author Thread
Post actions
I find this extremely unpleasant as an image. The editing looks very unskilled. I don't mind a heavy handed image, but this one looks poorly done. The strong difference in processing style from the lower portion of the image compared with the sky doesn't work well, making the pic look unfinished and I don't find any aspect of the composition compelling whatsoever.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Intense shadows in the clouds. I love to watch the clouds.
Post actions
Clouds appear kind of chunky.. actually have lots of depth. Interesting PP effect.
Post actions
Pretty job with the sky. I like the comp. Almost like an abstract.
Post actions
Lovely composition. Great clouds.
Post actions
Really nice texture in the sky.
Post actions
Nice study, ferocious clouds.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
interesting clouds but it seems a little over-processed... maybe too much neat image?
Post actions
Post actions
the clouds seem a bit too sharp
Post actions
Clever title and a beautiful image.
Post actions
scary clouds:/ a bit too over processed for me
Post actions
Fantastic clouds. I love the sky as the main subject.
Post actions
Dramatic sky, I like the layered look.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Very nice image. It's good to see a few "great" images. This is a perfect reflection of your abilities as a photographer.
Post actions
Looks a bit overprocessed. And looks like local weather change more than global climate change. Dramatic, though.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
selective color adds interest
Post actions
Right. The sun keeps our climate under control. And those clouds are so fasinating.
Post actions
Great PP job - love the tone - keep up the good work
Post actions
Very dramatic sky, love the tones.
Post actions
Post actions
Impressive sky. In combination with the colors is looks like a watercolor painting.
Post actions
The cloud details is great!! 6 , This would do great in a grey challenge
Post actions
Very smooth clouds, a lot of post-processing to get that done, I imagine. The colors and turbulence of the sky is unsettling, good job (though maybe lay off the post-processing, some?)
Post actions
Post actions
Amazing sky, very dramatic. Great post processing!!
Post actions
Post actions
To my eyes, the sky just doesn't look natural, perhaps too processed. I do like the water and horizon, though.
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting treatment of the clouds. They look very painted.
Post actions
Wow, the textures here are so smooth. This has a powerful feeling. I'd love to know how you edited this.
Post actions
Post actions
The clouds look so intense. Nice job showing how large they are.
Post actions
Wow! Looks eerily surreal.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
A little over processed for me but I love the subject. Nice dramatic sky.
Post actions
Post actions
I can feel the tempature change.
Post actions
Very interesting cloud formations.
Post actions
fantastic clouds! very dramatic scenery here
Post actions
Nice capture! Those clouds look wicked!
Post actions
Post actions
wow, the clouds are so dramatic. I like that you focused on that and not the horizon.
Post actions
Ok I know you were going for something here.. kind of looks neat but a lil over done. Like half painting have photograph.
Post actions
Neat dramatic sky! Nicely juxtaposed against the relatively calm waters.
Post actions
Not sure what happened. The clouds look fake. Too much processing?
Post actions
the clouds don't fit with the water...looks like 2 pictures
Post actions
cool sky, looks like three different skies in one, is this B&W or is this what it actually looked like? just wondering, either way, I like it
Post actions
interesting textures in the clouds
Post actions
i would rate this an 8 in basic editing, but because it is advanced it is hard to tell what was really captured still a 7
Post actions
Clouds seem really over processed to me when compared to the water.
Post actions
I like the composition on this one, but the clouds look a bit over processed.
Post actions
Post actions
Really like the picture, though the title doesn't do much for me.
Post actions
Fabulous clouds! Great shot.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
