Author Thread
Post actions
Thank you all for your comments! and votes too!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
A beautiful classic still life...I never tire of looking at these, particularly ones done as well is this one...excellent work.
Post actions
love the quiet feeling that comes out from this pic
Post actions
Great! The white vase does so much...
Post actions
good arrangement, good light,
Post actions
Lovely painting like composition with excellent lighting.
Post actions
nice setup, lighting, and depth.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Nice still life with a twist. Nice coloring.
Post actions
Love the tones and feel to this. Very old master feel to it.
Post actions
Not a huge fan of these types of still lifes, but feel compelled to let you know you may be changing my perception with this one. Unique and very appealing.
Post actions
Post actions
Very well done still life shot. Well arranged, excellent composition coloring and post processing.
Post actions
Stunning still life, very classic in feel, love the light
Post actions
impressive still life photo
Post actions
Post actions
Voted earlier coming back to leave comments now. I find that this still life is very appealing because of the arrangement of objects, the color, textures and the way the light plays upon them. Love the soft chocolate brown tones of the background and ground plane of this still life study. The light plays upon the fabric showing off variations in shades such that it highlights the soft feel of the fabric and shows off texture. There are some same variations in color shades that is found in the pomegranates. The round shape of the fruit is then also repeated in the shape of the vase. The inclusion of the single autumn branch in the vase adds a interesting curved line that bends down over the fruits thus leading the eye's attention back to those objects. I do have a critique and that is that there are two deep shadows that appear on the backdrop. What it does is breakup the flow of the texture and color shading of the rich brown background and introduces two shapes that detract. It is not the objects in the scene that are casting any shadows, but whatever it is could have been removed to as not cast that distracting shadow.
Post actions
I think it may have been a little better to crop tighter on the pot and the far left pomegranate. Cute out some of the dead space :) Just my .02
Post actions
Beautiful lighting and composition.
Post actions
A very nice, simple still life shot, the autumnal colors all work really well together.
Post actions
perfect still life. the vase (white) shows how well you exposed your picture. very well done.
Post actions
Post actions
imlvoe pomegranates! i was meaning to go buy one today. ill just look at your photo instead:)
Post actions
Wonderful shot with a great painterly quality, the lightting and color are perfect.
Post actions
Very pretty. Soft yet detailed. And mouth watering...
Post actions
Great PP job - love the tone - keeep up the good work and good luck in this challenge
Post actions
I'm not really into still life photography but this is very nice, great arrangement and colours. Best of luck 8
Post actions
Post actions
Oh this is lovely! The vase is gorgeous and the light is wonderful.
Post actions
Subject is very well done.
Post actions
Post actions
Classic still life photo. A tighter crop might be more effective.
Post actions
Classic still life, well done
Post actions
This is a classic still life captured perfectly. It also helps that I love pomegranates.
Post actions
Artfully arranged, very nice.
Post actions
A good earthy still life.
Post actions
This is nice. I could picture this hanging in a kitchen.
Post actions
Post actions
excellent still life & lighting , 7
Post actions
Lovely still life in a classic composition. Excellant.
Post actions
Really good still life shot. Would look nice framed and in a kitchen.
Post actions
I'm hoping to leave comments on as many photo's in this challenge as possible... out of (currently) 1124 images, I gave 31 of them a 9. Your image was one of those 31.
Post actions
I think the lighting could've been a little bit better to dark
Post actions
love the pomegranates and the cloth.. the pot and dried plant not so fab
Post actions
What a lovely still life. I like the compositiona lot. Makes me want to get out my oil paints...
Post actions
Post actions
Very good composition. Also like the white contrast of the vase. Nice image!
Post actions
Lit like the master used to paint!
Post actions
nice tones and pretty crisp too
Post actions
Nice still life. I love pomegranates!!
Post actions
Nice composition and I love the light.
Post actions
Lovely still life. Great composition and lighting.
Post actions
Very nice. I would've liked it better without the reflection on the pomegranates. 7
Post actions
A wonderful still life. I love the bleakness of it yet it exhibits so much warmth one can hardly see it.
Post actions
nice still life, good lighting
Post actions
I think this is absolutely Beautiful. I'd like to see more "oompf" put into the textures.
Post actions
Nice pic. Looks like one of the recent apple challenge pics...same feel. Wonder if it's the same person?
Post actions
The lighting might be a little soft overall.
Post actions
Post actions
this is lovely. tones are serene and warm. the vase hits just the right amount of "foil" to the earthy scene
Post actions
like the colors, vase, and pomegranates...but I don't like your choice of leaf...sorry
Post actions
Lovely composition and balance of colors, shapes and textures.
Post actions
Excellent still life, very Degas. Very nice choice of shapes and colors. Good contrast! 10
Post actions
Beautiful still life. I think something on the left to counteract that light colored vase would have been nice like green grapes but I like that the shape of the vase is like the fruit. Nice.
Post actions
Post actions
Stunning! I could see this hanging in an art gallery.
Post actions
Post actions
good lighting and nice warm color. The arrangement is a bit centered and misses depth
Post actions
nice. I'd like to see it cropped in about 15% personally, but it is nice.
Post actions
Like an old painting. Great composition.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
