Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Good lighting on the homes.
Post actions
I am not sure I like the pp here. Not voting anyway.
Post actions
Very sketchlike, nice vantage point.
Post actions
Looks like a neat town with a story to tell.
Post actions
Nicely processed hdr image.
Post actions
ominous clouds, scenic town, a castle, rippling water, good light - My, this has everything!!
Post actions
Post actions
Nicely processed.. Your shot brings out a lot of detail in the buildings by the shore.
Post actions
I never knew Whitby could be so photogenic!
Post actions
very nice...where exactly is this?
Post actions
nice hdr as it seems to be.. those houses could be sharper though
Post actions
Was this taken from the base of the lighthouse? I was there last year (My Dad lives there).. Interesting place.
Post actions
Post actions
Dramatic photo I quite like.
Post actions
The softness on the row of houses hurts this other wise very effective shot. 7
Post actions
Love the lighting highlights on the white row of buildings with red roofs. The structures at the top of the hill are tantalizingly interesting.
Post actions
Excellent post processing with great sharpness and detail.
Post actions
Nice composition, would be better with a subtler HDR effect
Post actions
Lovely processng and scene.
Post actions
a little over processed IMO, the halo between sky and earth is a little distracting.
Post actions
looks like a wonderful place to visit, i like the post procesing
Post actions
Very nice image. It's good to see a few "great" images. This is a perfect reflection of your abilities as a photographer.
Post actions
This is very pretty. Thanks for sharing.
Post actions
Great PP job - love the tone - keeep up the good work and good luck in this challenge
Post actions
The HDR-like treatment of this image is a little too heavy for my eyes - IMO the scene would benefit from a more delicate application of this editing style.
Post actions
so dramatic love that sky
Post actions
A lovely scene, I like all those red roofed houses along the hillside. The HDR is a bit overdone for my tastes but I am not a fan of HDR.
Post actions
Houses are over exp. Darker would do fine.
Post actions
The castle looks a little too shaded but a great looking take overall
Post actions
Post actions
Beautiful landscape which I don't feel needed to be so processed
Post actions
One of my favourite places! I like this composition, and the tone-mapping works well to bring out the sky as well as the land and water. It is a bit of a shame that the colour of the cottages on the harbour side has been leached out, as that is one of the aspects of Whitby that i find most charming.
Post actions
Coming back to comment...
Post actions
Beautiful view of the village and the abbey. The postprocessing gives this a dramatic feeling.
Post actions
Love the editing work. Gorgeous landscape and good detail. 8
Post actions
Interesting looking place. Those clouds look ominous.
Post actions
Good shot to give the HDR treatment
Post actions
Good pic but I would've liked to see more in focus.
Post actions
The lighting has a very unnatural feel.
Post actions
The post on this works well for the clouds but a lot of the light depth of the sky is lost. The overall depth works well here but the composition leaves this viewer wanting...
Post actions
Post actions
The clouds look menacing.
Post actions
I like the overall picture, in general, but the processing seems a bit heavy for my personal taste.
Post actions
What a wonderful palette of textures to feast upon!
Post actions
Nice moody sky, the ruins on the hill look great
Post actions
Whitby is heritage, so there's a point just for being Whitby. Magnificent foreboding sky, too. Just a wee bit of that HDR/painted postcard look hits me...
Post actions
Good verticals, good composition, the wharf and road make great leading lines
Post actions
Like looking at two pages of history at the same time! A lovely vista presented quite well and a good shot to linger with. Those structures on top of the hill are very impressive!
Post actions
Post actions
Perhaps another composition with something more dominant as the subject. Perhaps a rule of thirds composition? Great processing and light, though.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
