Author Thread
Post actions
Great picture. It's a shame it scored even after mine... I love photo that are a work of composition and ideas, and your is a good example of both.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Cool reflections of buildings we can see.
Post actions
My initial look at this was it was just OK. Then I read the title and then saw the reflections and it my reaction was WOW that's neat. I like it when photos trick me like that.
Post actions
Post actions
Whoa, great juxtoposition there, this is a very clever and well executed shot.
Post actions
Great pic, shame the water was a little wavy or this would have been even better that great.
Post actions
Fantastic. All the more intriguing for seeing the new only in reflection.
Post actions
Terrific! I love how this is not contrived, but wish for a bit warmer in tone.
Post actions
That is cool how the buildings reflect, but are not visible. Good capture.
Post actions
Post actions
you really have to work your imagination on this one...very nice...good colors...might try levels just a bit more
Post actions
What a great perspective shot! The confluence of the new reflected in the water and the old on the shore is great!
Post actions
The reflection in the pond throws you off. Good pic though.
Post actions
I give you 5 for great idea but I dont like the quality too much ...
Post actions
Took me a bit to see the reflection, good idea tho.
Post actions
Post actions
Awesome capture and presentation. Gorgeous. How cool are the reflections!
Post actions
intresting idea, but the water needs to be calmer to get a better reflection
Post actions
Whoa, really cool effect. I like how you combined Old and New through the reflection.
Post actions
I like how the reflection contradicts the scene.
Post actions
Great concept, maybe brighten it up a bit
Post actions
I wish the building had just a tiny bit more headroom but I'm assuming the treeline ended right where you shot it (seems that way in the reflection). Nice idea and well captured.
Post actions
I might have brought the crop up to remove some of the over exposed water. jmo
Post actions
What a wonderful composition showing the reflections of the modern buildings in the water, good eye.
Post actions
The perfect crop... subtle, and may not do well with voters, but interesting.
Post actions
You really do have to take your time with this image, read the title and take in what it offers. When you do you have a thought provoking and interesting photo, if you don't tqake a little time I fear you would just skip on by. Nice photo and great use of reflection. COuld have done with a tad more punch as the colours/light is a little flat. Well done and good luck for the rest of the challenge.
Post actions
Lovely image with wonderful reflections to contrast the old and the new. 7
Post actions
Wonderful thinking here. Great one
Post actions
There seems to be a lot in this challenge, the composition is good, but the lighting just comes across as very bland.
Post actions
what a dichotomy - great shot!
Post actions
Nice juxtaposition of the old & new.
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting contrast of lines and textures.
Post actions
The dichotomy was well spotted.
Post actions
Excellent POV, using the reflection in this way is really creative. Congratulations!!
Post actions
The contrast between the simple structure in a park setting, and the reflections of the towering city behind is really nicely captured. I like it!
Post actions
interesting presentation, I would have cropped off more of the bottom
Post actions
Nice view and composition with only the reflections of the new buildings.
Post actions
How cool, love how the reflections have worked out
Post actions
Unique concept and very well depicted!! 7
Post actions
TOTALLY cool that the scene seems one way and the reflection tells the real story.
Post actions
Post actions
whoa, really cool reflection, I've never seen a reflection like this, really well captured, Tokyo, I love the city, there's a lot of beauty to be found there
Post actions
Very natural looking colors. Love the ripples and the birds. Good crop to.
Post actions
Great angle. Like these shots where the origin of the reflection cannot be seen. Objective here well achieved.
Post actions
This would be really cool to see this at night too.
Post actions
Great shot. The title tells all.
Post actions
almost whizzed by this, LOVE the subtelty of the reflections contrast! nice catch! I'm going to give you a 10 to make up for the many people that will not even notice.
Post actions
wonderfully captured reflections of the new building in great contrast to the old. very well presented
Post actions
i liked the idea of having the new buildings in the reflection. i would suggest increasing the saturation a bit.
Post actions
Post actions
Wonderful framing. Great idea.
Post actions
Post actions
wish to see more trees and less water - just my opp
Post actions
Post actions
Nice idea, I'd be keen to know if including the buildings as well as their reflections added more impact
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Great composition. Had to do a double take on this one! Although I think a different time of day would have brought out more colors. It seems a little flat. Still very creative. Good eye.
Post actions
Great use of reflection to make the modern seem surreal while the old ways endure in reality.
Post actions
Great juxtaposition, I nearly didn't see the reflection, doh!
Post actions
I like the reflections in the water - nice shot.
Post actions
Nice find with the high-rise reflections.
Post actions
Good thinking, I like the idea a bunch!
Post actions
very sneaky, wish the water was calmer
Post actions
Nice use of capturing contrasting styles..... good eye for seeing it.
Post actions
Nicely observed (I wish the light was more dramatic)
Post actions
Post actions
pity the highrises werent in the image too would have been a nice full reflection capture
Post actions
are the buildings reflected behind that grove of trees or behind the photographer?
Post actions
Very very clever idea, but I don't think you've pulled it off, sorry. If you can, I'd definately work on that though, there's a brilliant image just waiting in there, well spotted.
Post actions
I have no idea how you got this...is this a merge?
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
