Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Beautiful DOF and composition, I love the deatil in the petals.
Post actions
lacks composition maybe if you had been back a little further
Post actions
Nice job filing the frame with the bright flower.
Post actions
Post actions
pretty color on the rose..might have done a crop without the leaves...they distract from you pretty flower and that alone could have "filled" the frame
Post actions
sorry this is not enough for me , especially for this challenge , is it really your best?
Post actions
Flower looks so good I might have even cropped the leaves and wall out of this one.
Post actions
bold composition, needs an even shallower DOF 6
Post actions
Very interesting choice. This would be a good photo for an ad about rose spray against the blight.
Post actions
Post actions
dont like the processing of this - the details are gone - 4
Post actions
crop is good, focus seems a bit off
Post actions
pretty rose, nice job blurring out the background
Post actions
I like your composition and you've gotten a lot of detail. Seems a bit overexposed though. Would like to see it a bit darker with deeper colours.
Post actions
Nice rose. Lacking a bit in clarity.
Post actions
Good idea. I think the crop might hurt the score. Good pic.
Post actions
Lush flower! Lighting is a bit off.
Post actions
Lovely red rose in combination with the green leafs on the background. The drops gives some nice reflection.
Post actions
Looks nice flower. I would have taken only flower, omitting the bad leaves and brick in the BG.
Post actions
Post actions
Colors seem a little washed out. Maybe it was a hazy day?
Post actions
Lovely patterns with the rose petals.
Post actions
The flower is very pink and really dominates this image. Good focus and DOF
Post actions
The red really pops against the background.
Post actions
Beautiful rose. I would have love to see just the petails. I am not too hot about the spotted leaves and the brick background.
Post actions
Good detail and color, nice placement.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
I'd like to see this one without the centered division between the rose and your background.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
I see black leaf spot ;-) Very common around here, and I'm too lazy and/or environmentally conscious to spray. The rose looks really lush, though. You got nice depth to it.
Post actions
pretty rose, but i think it could use some contrast boost and saturation adjustment. jsut to really "make" it
Post actions
A rose by any other name... my wife's favorite flower, regardless of the thorns.
Post actions
Good color and focus on the rose, though I do find the bricks and leaves to be a bit of a distraction.
Post actions
Better spray that blight before it gets out of hand.
Post actions
i like the off center rose, but the leaves and the background are a little flat, taking away from the composition.
Post actions
The composition is quite nice. I wouldn't mind seeing just the flower though.... such great patterns going on.
Post actions
A little to much sun I think for this. Next time get it after a rain or wait for some shade but the flower is a great choice.
Post actions
you pushed contrast and saturation too far here. compsoition is unfortunate, the background rather distracts - could also have been avoided with less DOF
Post actions
I like your use of the rule of thirds, but my eyes keep getting distracted by that holly leaf that's in focus on the right.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
