nice shot! great blur on the water, altho I think it's a little overexposed on the left side. maybe some shadow/highlight work could make the rock look a little better and tone down some of the white. But still, excellent photo, IMO!
This is a nice shot but the main visual element (to my eye, the rock in the foreground) is only horizontally centered.The challenge guidelines specified dead center so, in fairness, I shaved a point of for that. I gave it a five. The water looks great but the rocks are very contrasty.
Nice image, I like the smooth impression of the water. Don't like the border though. Background seems a little bit out of focus, would have been better either sharp or much more blurred.