I guess everyone sees something different in a picture.
I only hit yours as a 5, and suppose it was the too washed out brightness of it.
Composition was great.
Thanks for voting for me this image was pretty impromptu. I can't say that I'm a big drinker, but I do like to collect different glassware. Also if you were wondering port is the alcohol in the shot glass, it's all that I had at the time of the shot. Tequila or scotch may have been better ;-)
One of my three favorites in the Habit challenge. This type of shot has been done many times before, but for me this is an example of a fresh take that has a lot of impact for me. Very well executed IMHO.
I like this one
the only problem seems to be that the reflection is washed out, maybe there is to much general light in the front
I think if you crop the the reflection out at the start of the alcohol and reduce the white space at the top to balance the new reflection you would end up with a much bolder picture - 8
I really like the composition and colors in this shot. The only thing that I would do is try to use a polaring filter (if you can use one on your camera) to eliminate the reflections and glare from the glass. This would make this shot a 10.