So many entries that show a person with a finger pressed to their lips. I know it's meant to imply "Quiet or Be silent" but the image does just not convey a feeling of "Silence" to me. 5
good: good rendering of challenge theme. i know what she wants. this is one of those shots that seems to break a few rules in a good way. also hard to put a finger on it, like the somewhat blown highlights and flat lighing. i also like the pink hue it has.
bad: like i said normally i wouldn't like the blown highlights like this but here i think it's ok. not much i don't like really. i started out thinking 6-7 but now i say 8.