I went out to my favorite tree, hoping for a ray of sunrise under the clouds along the horizon... nothing.
This was my best shot of the batch.
PP...
adjust contrast, levels, shadows and highlights, apply photofilter, variations, grunge filter, resize, USM, noise reduction, more variations and a dash of hope for a score of around 6.0
lens set at 31mm
manual settings, OS off, shot from tripod
Post challenge - I was asked to validate during the challenge, a first for me. But, interestingly enough, my score moved up quite a bit after validating.
Statistics
Place: 67 out of 209 Avg (all users): 5.8798 Avg (commenters): 7.1429 Avg (participants): 5.5904 Avg (non-participants): 6.1200 Views since voting: 987 Views during voting: 294 Votes: 183 Comments: 9 Favorites: 1 (view)
I don't know how you did the texture - looks almost like it was shot thru another viewfinder or an older camera. But it looks wonderful and antiquish. Love the colortone - gives off a rainy day kind of mood.
I will be curious how you do with this border...I like it...others won't, I like what it does to/for the photo...will be anxious to read the other comments...extra point for taking the leap
What really works is that vignette/border. Suits the image. Great use of stark black in the silhouetted scene. I also like that greenish tinge to the duotone.
Background seems to have too much noise. Could be that you intended for that, judging by the choice in frame, which is fine but the sharpness of the foreground doesn't seem to quite match that old fashioned sepia toned photo quality. Nice subject, good composition. 7.