I really think this should have scored higher. The environment around the subject tells much more about a person's personality than a posed look on the face. I think most of these submissions were about "mood" and "expression" than about personality. Or did I miss the mark, again?
I've voted on 62% of the photos so far and this is one of the few photos I've seen that actually meets the intent of the challenge, other than just shoe-horning some random portrait. That being said, good luck with your photo. So, you've got numerous books about the Bible & Christianity, many Bibles, and "The God Delusion". Alright. Well, you also have some Harry Potter books - some people think that's just as bad as atheism. However, some people think that their cats are human. Moving on...