Obviously everyone has their different tastes. I like this one better than the desat version. The only thing I don't like in this one is that blue drum with the dismembered bodies stuffed into it. (ok, well that's just an assumption, but I watch enough crime reality shows to know what I am talking about).
I like this version much better, less emphasis on the house and more on the whole scene. This version has more of a storybook or fairy tale quality, as if you were reading book and the main character stumbles upon this shack in the woods. Nice pic with great colors.
Really different moods created between this and the partial desat. I'm leaning toward to more warm approach of this one. In either case, nice use of the LB! Now start adding your aperture info....