Wow! I can't believe you scored this low. How anyone can rate this a 2 or 3 or anything lower than a 7, I have no idea. I still say this is a 10. I can't believe someone called this out of focus. The focus is perfect where you wanted it.
I really like your color and composition, but wish for more contrast of focus between the flower and background. Still a nice photo, but it might have more punch with a non-blury subject...
The background is great, you cut some parts of the flower and it's OOF, which is not good. Try to show all the object next time, a bigger part of the background and more focus and you'll have a great photo in my opinion! Good luck!
When I opened this picture, I used a word that is not suitable for use on this website. This is probably the best photo I have seen of a lilly. I myself have taken many pictures of them. This is brilliant!
My absolute favourite in this challenge. If I were to try to explain what bokeh is to someone else, who doesnt know the term, this photo would be what I choose to show them as a perfect example. I expect to see this on the front page next tuesday.