Author Thread
Post actions
Great idea for this, the bronze-y cutter stands out very well, and well-lit. Congrats!
Post actions
Great image Joe. Congratulations! I think your copyright message is a bit extreme for a 720 by 527 pixel image :)Message edited by author 2008-12-27 16:32:33.
Post actions
Post actions
The copyright message is a bit harsh on this site IMHO
Post actions
Great photo, and in the holiday spirit, too.
Post actions
Post actions
super job joe!!! congrats you are definitely on a roll
Post actions
Nice lighting and patterns.
Post actions
Congratulations on your Second place win, great job and very creative. I bet the cookies would of been good too. :)
Post actions
You went to all this work to make the dough and you didn't bake it?? Silly man!! (but great shot :D )
Post actions
Post actions
congrats. I wonder how many people have a ribbon picture that doesn't appear on their home page? Frustrating but reassuring at the same time....
Post actions
Congrats! I not only LOVE this picture, I LOVE it when I read someone used common lighting and still ribboned. Hope lives!!!!!
Post actions
Congrats on your ribbon, I am so glad this won!
Post actions
Originally posted by bvy:
I like this a lot. Am I to understand you used your existing in-home kitchen lighting, and didn't use any strobes, flashes or professional equipment?
Post actions
:) Yummy! It makes me feel all Christmassy and festive :) Congratulations!!!
Post actions
I like this a lot. Am I to understand you used your existing in-home kitchen lighting, and didn't use any strobes, flashes or professional equipment?
Post actions
Congratulations on your excellent picture and ribbon. X-mas came early for you :)
Post actions
Love the simplicity of this (and the lighting). Big congrats on your ribbon, Joe.
Post actions
Congratulations, Joe! Fabulous win!
Post actions
way to go Joe, you are on a roll Grats on second place
Post actions
So simple and yummy and you got to eat them afterwards! Well done on the red Joe!
Post actions
Well done on your ribbon :) (I gave you an 8!) Really happy that you got ribboned :)
Post actions
Nicely done Joe! I gave this an 8. :) congrats on the ribbon.
Post actions
Post actions
Congratulations, nice setup and shot.
Post actions
Great idea and I love the shot. Congratulations on your ribbon.
Message edited by author 2008-12-22 00:20:40.
Post actions
Simple and effective, congrats Joe!
Post actions
Congrats Joe! Marverlous idea and shot. Go....oh....What the heck....go Islanders anyway!
Post actions
Congratulations on the ribbon!!! Doin the happy dance yet?? :)
Post actions
CONGRATS on your ribbon!!! Great, deserving shot. :) -Magen
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
cute idea - and this is exactly how my cookies line up!
Post actions
Pretty - I love the copper cookie cutter. Maybe if the light was a little warmer the dough might have tied in better with the cutter. The tones just don't mesh well to my eye. Maybe a warming filter applied just to the dough? 6
Post actions
Post actions
oh beautiful! i love the shadows, and the composition. some may not like the border, but i really do. great work!
Post actions
Nice lighting on this one. The border wasn't necessary, I don't think -- at least not to the left and right.
Post actions
simple concept that has been well executed, 9
Post actions
Very nicely done. The copper cookie cutter really makes the image.
Post actions
I like the picture. Nice touch with leaving the cutter. Not a fan of the frame.
Post actions
Post actions
Yum. Not only a great idea for the challenge, and well done, but you get cookies out of the deal. Bonus!!
Post actions
Great shot!! Perfect lighting on the cutter..
Post actions
yummy - the details are very good and the composition is simple and clean
Post actions
Nice, simple composition - I like the subtle shadow.
Post actions
Post actions
wonderfully clear and sharp!
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
I love this image, it would make a beautiful print for the kitchen. Great colors.
Post actions
This is my absolute favourite in the challenge, I just love it! I thought of using a star cookie cutter and making cookies but I knew I wouldn't be able to make perfectly shaped cookies. But you were clever enough to use the dough. Smartie!
Post actions
Post actions
Great idea and composition!
Oh, Sugar Cookies
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
