Author Thread
Post actions
What Sandy says. I was so sure that this and Judi's shot were both top three... Don't let the score get you down, this is a wonderful image.
Post actions
Often I'm confused by what the voters pick as the highest rated photos in a challenge -- but I don't think I've ever been more disappointed than in this one. Photos like this -- and like Judi's are amazing landscape photos. For photos like this to be given sub-6 scores is a travesty!
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I love the graininess of the sky. The brown of the water draws my eye's focus from the sky though, so I wonder if this would have been better completely B & W.
Post actions
very interesting color choice
Post actions
Good effort, technique still to be improved: though the star trails are very little, hardly visible, the sky is noisy.
Post actions
A bit too noisy. I like the tones though...
Post actions
For some reason, the graininess works for me in this photo: 8
Post actions
WOW great shot, love the wood in the foreground and the stars are WOW 7
Post actions
Cool shot, great comp but looks a bit noisy to me.
Post actions
nice composition - the rotation of the stars is a cool effect
Post actions
Post actions
your shot looks a little noisy???
Post actions
I really like the whole day / night dichotomy here. Good job - 7.
Post actions
Absolutely stunning. Hope for top three for you.
Post actions
Looks like you may have had company at this spot. I think your desat-look works a bit better
Post actions
This has a vintage look to it.
Post actions
beautiful, sky is a little noisy, but with a long exposure like this, i dont blame ya. nicely composed as well
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
