I know the pp is not working here. as an explanation, but not an excuse, i had waited too long to enter this challenge and rushed it to get it by deadline. literally, 11:58. i love this shot and will put it in my portfolio with better pp for sure. thanks for the comments, i agree with all of them!
The vignetting seems a bit heavy for my taste, and not sure if it is due to the vignette or sharpening, but a strange halo'ing effect is evident around some parts of the rider/horse, most noticeably above the horse's rear and at the forefront of its chest/front left leg.
This is one where I really wish I could see it larger. As presented, there is little detail in the coat of the horse, giving it the appearance of a model. No vote.
A wonderful capture. I'd give this another go in PP and see what else you can get because you have a good shot to work with. Maybe less is better? Not too big of a fan of the style of vignette applied here.
This one is very cool, I don“t really dig the very obviously fake vignetting, I often add it afterwards and I try to make it less subtle, not maybe for me to judge on how well I accomplish that. Also the very strong halo around the horse and rider is a bit too much. The colors, moment and composition all make up for that though so I gave it a 7, great shot.