Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The cropped bottom lost a point.
Post actions
Cropped too closely at the bottom, but otherwise well done.
Post actions
Post actions
i dont like the crop on the bottom, its too tight and its taking away from your product. the background is almost obnoxiously bright as well
Post actions
Irish Merlot? I'm in! Send me some! Good shot, well lit, just wish bottles weren't cropped at bottom. Bottles could also be spaced a little farther apart, or one slightly behind the other to give greater DOF.
Post actions
Cropping just a little off the bottom of the bottles doesn't look deliberate.
Post actions
Composition feels unbalanced, and I don't like how the bigger bottle is cropped at the bottom.
Post actions
Very nice, black on white looks good. Crop's a wee bit tight at the bottom.
Post actions
the composition is a bit odd, specially in the bottom, but I think you did a good job with the lighting
Post actions
bottom is cut off....doesn't strike me as appropriate
Post actions
Shame about the bottom of the bottles missing. I always like to see the bottom of the bottle!
Post actions
2x Spelling mistakes in the title and I feel cropping the bottom of the bottles is a mistake.
Post actions
This is cropped too close on the bottom and it seems a bit tilted
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
