Author Thread
Post actions
Excellent Parody, Great Lighting and Pose. Congrats on your ribbon!
Post actions
wonderful shot and well deserved ribbon. nice work ;-)
Post actions
Whoot! congratulations on getting the set of all 3 ribbons with this great take on a 'classic' shot.
Post actions
very well done! congrats on the red!
Post actions
Lovely shot congrats on a fine image and your Ribbon
Post actions
Excellent job. The legs make this shot for me -- they do almost look real. (In fact, viewing from the thighs to the right, I'd have a hard time guessing that that wasn't real flesh.) Congrats on the RED!
Post actions
Excellent shot, congrats!
Post actions
This is quite exquisite. The "missing thumb" freaks me out a little too :-) Plus, at first glance I thought someone was messing with us and calling a real baby a doll... It's a heck of a nice shot, and even beyond the technicals its mysterious real/unreal dichotomy sets it apart in this challenge.
Post actions
Congratulations, very cool shot, the doll almost looks life like.
Post actions
A hearty congrats to you on your ribbon!!! Well done!
Post actions
Post actions
Congrats on getting the full line of colors :)
Post actions
Excellent parody. Ann would be proud of you. Congrats!Message edited by author 2008-09-10 09:49:40.
Post actions
Beautiful for the Red Ribbon! Congrats. It's a brilliantly creative doll shot!
Post actions
HEE HEE - those "real" looking dolls creep me out. Great tribute to Geddes work and boy do I ever agree with you about basic editing. :~)
Post actions
When I saw this title, I thought it was saying "elephant", whoops. Really though, incredible shot, awesome lighting, nice idea and very well executed.
Post actions
Congrats on the Red, very realistic image!!
Post actions
Congrats on your Red this was one of my favorites. Simple,brilliant idea plus beautiful lighting and set up.
Post actions
Congratulations on your Ribbon, was won my favorites. :)
Post actions
I wish I had voted in this challenge. This is brilliant. Congrats on the ribbon!
Post actions
wonderful picture,well done and congratulations
Post actions
Love it! I think I would of reshot it for the thumb thing but its sensational.
Post actions
amazing!
Post actions
Now that I know it was yours, I'm sure it was ironic and don't regret the points i gave out. Congrats on the red!
Post actions
I told you you would ribbon...well done! Congrats...
Post actions
Congrats on the 2nd place ribbon! I, too, thought it was real from the thumb. Great toning!
Post actions
Looks so real in the thumbnail I was going to blast you for DNMC! ;)
Post actions
Post actions
Perfect. Congratulations on a ribbon much deserved.
Post actions
Beautiful image-- well deserved.
Post actions
Wonderful shot !!! Congrats on the Red.
Post actions
Congratulations! This is a beautiful Photo. Well done!
Post actions
Congratulations, well done.
Post actions
Amazingly life-like, a really gorgeous image. Congratulations on your red.
Post actions
VERY pleased to see a B&W do well - nicely done and 'grats on the ribbon!
Post actions
A lovely image, and almost looks real.....
RED ribbon.....
Post actions
Now you have the full set of ribbons. Congrats! You're on quite a roll recently.
Post actions
Post actions
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
back to bump you up, this is my fav by far, the lighting is perfect, love the title, perfect composition for such a life like doll
Post actions
Wonderful imitation of the shots I always love of 'real' babies.
Post actions
Nice clear shot. A bit unsettling, but very neat and clear.
Post actions
Post actions
This is one of the most incredible doll scenes I could ever even imagine. Just extraordinary. 10
Post actions
lol! That's pretty creepy actually! Nice lighting and take on a classic shot. Ahh! I kept thinking it looked weird... i think you used the wrong arm! Usually the thumb is towards the camera... seems like a nit pick but with the arm that and the angle the hand is at it almost appears like someone is holding the baby up behind their back...
Post actions
Well done. I had to look several times to assure myself a doll was used!
Post actions
Great lighting and composition. Well done. I'm sure this gonna gets into Top 5, if not a ribbon.
Post actions
Wow this is beautiful, best in the challenge.
Post actions
Nice play on an old theme. The mono suits this better than colour.
Post actions
well conceived, I really like this one.
Post actions
beautiful photo! great idea! the baby looks very real, and B/W gave an old fashion view.
Post actions
Bar none, the most creative take on the challenge, and gorgeously shot.
Post actions
wow i thought the baby was real
Post actions
very beautiful I'll be shocked if this doesn't ribbon or end up in the top 5
Post actions
love the geddes parody here....
Post actions
not sure if this is overly cliché. very well executed in any case. maybe I'll bump you up later.
Post actions
Post actions
What a good idea, its almost life-like.
Post actions
love the tones in this.. really great shot
Post actions
a ribbon winner...good luck in advance
Post actions
Terrific conceptualization! Excellent in light and composition!
Post actions
What a precious idea. Lovely and clear too.
Post actions
Obviously, this is a very cool photo. To me, personally, it seems unnatural to have the doll held with this hand and the thumb facing away, so I'd like to swap arms. However, the direction of the light and the proportion of the image is excellent.
Post actions
This is absolutely beautiful. I love portrais like this of fathers with their newborns, and this is just as lovely.
Post actions
L'enfant
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
