Well geez, I can't help myself if I'm in McHaffies and there *just happens* to be a bunch of Barbies with their fake tans, asinine smiles, vacant eyes and ginormous hair just waiting for me to come along and suck their pitiful little souls out of their plastic bodies with my camera. So I put em out of their misery.
pp: RAW conversion, crop, curves, brightness/contrast, hue/saturation, resize, usm, smart sharpen, save for web.
Statistics
Place: 81 out of 108 Avg (all users): 4.7425 Avg (commenters): 6.1429 Avg (participants): 4.7292 Avg (non-participants): 4.7479 Views since voting: 1626 Views during voting: 276 Votes: 167 Comments: 10 Favorites: 0
Heh! I didn't vote on this challenge, partly because I was on vacation and didn't have my usual time on the computer, and partly because of my embarassing score in this challenge. I did, however, wander through the challenge just to see what was there, and this one totally cracked me up! So VERY appropriate for a "dolls" challenge in so many ways. And your description is priceless. From the ol' DPC perspective, what got you scorewise were the technicals. I really do like the choice of focus on the 2nd doll (at least one other commenter did too) but there are those for whom something in the foreground out of focus is distressing (it's just the way some are, can't fix it). A bit of noise, yes. Might have been really funny to NeatImage them to death to make them look even more like dolls.... heh. But the noise actually seems to serve a purpose, since they're already plastic enough, don't you think? A final thought - my grandmother always told me to arrange things in odd - 3, 5, 7, etc - rather than even. Not sure how much difference that makes. Your arrangement here is good, but were it mine I'd crop a bit off the top to box them in some and to take away a bit of the white fluffy cloudlike thing in the upper right. You did notice, I hope, that your commenters enjoyed this.
A bit of high ISO noise on Barb and her cleavage. Just a little noise reduction could smooth that out. I think the composition is a bit off, the one in focus seems squeezed too far over in the frame.
I like how you've chosen to focus on the second doll instead of the one in front. I would like it better if this doll's dress were not quite as crazy. I would rather the focus be her face, and I find the pattern very distracting.