You must retain your original, unedited file (exactly as recorded by your camera), and provide it to the Site Council along with a list of your editing steps within 48 hours of any validation request. Files that have been saved or altered with any editing or transfer software are NOT originals.
Statistics
Views since voting: 3972 Views during voting: 296 Comments: 35 Favorites: 8 (view)
that is my opinion, and by the looks of it i am in the minority.
Yes, you are very much in the minority. I don't think the whites are muddy at all, and the lighting is beautiful, as is the overall wow factor and the composition.
I am so sorry about your grandmother! She can count on my prayers. And I agree: There will be plenty of redemption ribbons for you! Keep turning out photos like this, and we'll be seeing you in a week or two!
Hi everyone.
Thanks for your comment.
I know the rules and there is no photoshop work on this photo, but problem is ... My grandmother died and ... you know ... . This is the GOD RULES!
Pray for my grandmother.
I'll try for another challenge.
not to sound completely rude, but this image isn't technically well done from a commercial standpoint. yes, it is composed very well, but the lighting is very flat and the whites are very muddy. nothing in this image really pops out to me. that is my opinion, and by the looks of it i am in the minority.
Seems like a new member here. Maybe he didn't understand the rules. Maybe there is some Photoshop work done that he didn't know was against the rules?
Originally posted by Jac:
DQ sucks. Why wouldn't you give your original?
This rule should be modified to at least give the member one week to reply.
DQs are very unfortunate...but this individual has been around the site for more than a year, so they had time to understand the rules about retaining unedited files.
I can't fault anything about it except that the idea is very old and you didn't add anything to the concept other than to reshoot it and in that you did very well. The lighting is exquisite.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
