Besides the easily noted crime scene here, what I noticed on this was the shadows/light from an open door. Adds a sense of reality in walking into a scene like this. Kudos.
This is a really cool shot and by far the best in the challenge. It's graphic enough yet it doesn't go overboard. what really makes it great is the processing. It kinda has a cartoony feel to it. 10
Really good use of the numbers by the clues, it draws me into the shot a little more. I like the tone mapping in the shed it brings out a lot of detail in the wood. My only critisism of this is that it's very weighted on the right with little interest on the left. I really like the window in the shot so the framing is good, but I would have just prefered something on the left in the setup that makes that part of the frame more interesting. Top 5 for me anyway
Most of the elements are here, it's just the tone-mapping - if I were voting, I would probably knock it down for a photo/challenge like this. No vote, I'm in this one.