Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
I really like everything here except one small detail - the white halo around her head (high marks regardless ). Aside from that, this shot rocks for bringing out the raw emotion feel.
Post actions
Good shot except for the lighting.
Post actions
framing and composition is nice, but the execution and post processing could use work. she isn't really in focus and she's oversharpened I think. That said, its a good concept.
Post actions
very poignant and dramatic 9
Post actions
Good composition, detail... like the b&w... 9
Post actions
Nice attempt but subject is too dark and a lot of reflections to her right which I did not understand how they relate to the scene.
Post actions
Technically pretty lousy, with poor focus, grain, banding and blown highlights... but good concept and a outstanding point of view. 8
Post actions
good title, impactful image...good gritty edit...
Post actions
Good take on the challenge. Processing works well. Bumping up.
Post actions
The lighting and composition works really well - the hand makes the photo/story for me - 8
Post actions
This for some reason remonds me of the opening sequence of Scream. No idea why, as nothing like this happens in that film. A bit too grainy for me.
Post actions
the story behind this is great.....something we can all relate to. (the possibility of a home invasion) scary stuff...not sure if its 'crime scene' tho
Post actions
Great setup and idea, but too grainy.
Post actions
Good comp but it looks over-processed, particularly the rim around her hair?
Post actions
Interesting concept, though I just wish it gave me a bit more. The blown highlights on the fingers are a distraction.
Post actions
like the scene but it is a bit on the dark side
Post actions
The grain/noise might be a tad bit heavy. And the area just above her head looks strange. No vote, I'm in this one.
Post actions
The setup and the expressions are great. While the grainy feel of the image adds to the reality of shooting in low light, the image looks over sharpened to me and some blown highlights on the edges of the furniture are a bit distracting
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
