Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Good subject. I'd like it recomposed.
Post actions
nice diagonal composition.
Post actions
quite a plain shot... it is clear... it is ok composed but... the subject is kind of lost in the scene with that grass and the white of snow...
Post actions
Post actions
The object is fully centered, which doesn't work for me here. With that title I also would like the see the rust.
Post actions
The only problem with B&W is that you can't see if it's rusty... It's a bit of an unusual angle, too, but I like the snow and (ignoring the rust issue) the B&W gives an aged feel which works in this case. Personally, it's not particularly inspiring, but it fit's the challenge well. It could do with being larger though - you're given 640 pixels and really those should be used to get the extra gravitas. 5.
Post actions
I'd like it color. THe composition is great, but it doesn't look very rusty, just black
Post actions
could use some more sharpening i think (USM). maybe a tad more exposrure (1/3 stop) or more contrast
Post actions
Interesting subject, composition seems a bit unimaginative though. Melting snow looks good in b&w.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
