Good idea, but it falls short to expectations for some reason. I think if the ripple lines were level (horizontal) that would have helped -- also a little more stillness in the water. It's obvious too fast that this was shot reflected in water.
The photo has a lot of potential, but it takes "work" to imagine what you are seeing. It might have benefited from having a portion of the boat in the image. I also think a polarizing filter would have improved the image.
This is sort of interesting to look at. Sort of impressionistic. I'm still attempting to figure out how you did this. Is this a reflection turned upside down?
would have been better if you could see the person being reflected...without that, it kind of distracts from the point of the photo in this instance...there are too many ripples in the water to even vaguely make out what is happening.
Interesting. I would have had a hard time finding the boat without the pink of the (presumable) fisherperson's clothes, but they took me straight there. Different, but I like it.
Interesting concept, reasonably well done. Subjectively, it doesn't do much for me, but that doesn't take away its intrinsically artistic quality. Looks like a Posthumous nominee.
I'v been scratching my head trying to figure out if this is just a photoshop "effect" or if the ripples are part of the original. I'd think it was taken from under water except for the weeds by the bow - nicely done (8)