Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Your edit works for me. Seems a little dark but I suspect that was so the smoke would show up better. Very good composition: 10
Post actions
Love the selective desat on this. Very nice shot.
Post actions
I'm kind of anti-selective desat these days, but this is well done.
Post actions
I think the desat works wonderfully for this, and I love how the smoke from the stack is so well isolated from the sky. This is a very nice presentation.
Post actions
Nice shot but it may suffer from too much pp. The clouds just above the tree line look un-natural. I would have liked more water in the foreground as well. Over all nice shot though.
Post actions
good selective desat here
Post actions
Post actions
I like the PP it just seems a little to dark, maybe a little more detail. Still a very good image. 7
Post actions
this for me is too dark and the frame detracts
Post actions
Great historic, regional appeal! Would have liked to seen a more brilliant-colored use of selective desat to make it *pop*
Post actions
Love the tones and desat.
Post actions
I'm not a big fan of selective desat - I think I would prefer a total B&W treatment - still a clear well composed shot.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
