Highly proficient - good sense of smoothness and weight in the stones - the green has the look of over-sharpening, but that may just be the way it looks (!). A very dpc photo, I would say - so proficient not only in its technique but in its targeting of audience. I'm sure it will do well.
This is a very attractive photo. I don't think that stricty speaking, it portrays chaos, I think it illustrates another condition, perhaps the life force winning through whatever the condiitons However it is so good that it gets a good
score from me.